Archive for the 'RNA' Category

« Previous Entries
Next Page »

The Worst Theory

Posted in Origin of Life, RNA on September 24th, 2012 by chunkdz

Harold Bernhardt outlines the failings of the RNA World Hypothesis, and makes his case for "proteins first".

Some memorable quotes:

"The RNA World scenario is bad as a scientific hypothesis"

-Eugene Koonin

“[The RNA world hypothesis] has been reduced by ritual abuse to something like a creationist mantra”

-Charles Kurland

"I view it as little more than a popular fantasy."

-Charles Carter

11 Comments »

Throwing Down the Gauntlet

Posted in Genome, RNA on March 13th, 2010 by Bradford

Richard Sternberg opens his post with this statement:

I have long questioned the assumption that most genomic DNA sequences are “nonsensical” or “junk.” And given the data that have emerged over the past seven or so years, a functionalist view of genome has robust empirical support. It is for this reason that I think many of the arguments presented by the Biologos Foundation are “wrong on many counts,” to borrow a phrase from Darrel Falk.

Sternberg's attention was drawn to this post by Darrel Falk who in turn was critiquing Stephen Meyer. This may be familiar ground to readers of Telic Thoughts as criticisms of Falk have been previously noted at this blog. The exact comment made by Falk which Sternberg notes is:

Read the rest of this entry »

73 Comments »

Slicing and Dicing Falk: Part Two

Posted in Books, Origin of Life, RNA on January 31st, 2010 by Bradford

Stephen Meyer, author of Signature in the Cell wrote Response to Darrel Falk’s Review of Signature in the Cell. A prior post focused on the first few paragraphs. Continuing with the article:

Falk first cites a scientific study published last spring after my book was in press. The paper, authored by University of Manchester chemist John Sutherland and two colleagues, does partially address one of the many outstanding difficulties associated the RNA world, the most popular current theory about the origin of the first life.

Starting with a 3-carbon sugar (D-gylceraldehyde), and another molecule called 2-aminooxazole, Sutherland successfully synthesized a 5-carbon sugar in association with a base and a phosphate group. In other words, he produced a ribonucleotide. The scientific press justifiably heralded this as a breakthrough in pre-biotic chemistry because previously chemists had thought (as I noted in my book) that the conditions under which ribose and bases could be synthesized were starkly incompatible with each other.

Nevertheless, Sutherland’s work does not refute the central argument of my book, nor does it support the claim that it is premature to conclude that only intelligent agents have demonstrated the power to produce functionally-specified information. If anything, it illustrates the reverse.

Very true. Sutherland's work is causally inadequate as an explanatory model for the issues raised in Meyer's book.

Read the rest of this entry »

8 Comments »

Berlinski stirring the pot

Posted in Origin of Life, RNA on January 27th, 2010 by Bradford

Introducing David Berlinski:

Having with indignation rejected the assumption that the creation of life required an intelligent design, Mr Fletcher has persuaded himself that it has proceeded instead by means of various chemical scenarios.

These scenarios all require intelligent intervention. In his animadversions, Mr Fletcher suggests nothing so much as a man disposed to denounce alcohol while sipping sherry.

Heh, heh. Vintage Berlinski.

Read the rest of this entry »

109 Comments »

"If pigs could fly"

Posted in Origin of Life, RNA, Self-organization on January 15th, 2010 by Bilbo

I just tried reading the 2008 paper of the late Leslie Orgel, long time origin of life researcher, which assessed the plausibility of existing self-organizations theories of the origin of life. Most of the article was way over my head. But I think I understood the final sentence:
Read the rest of this entry »

51 Comments »

The Elegance of Complication?

Posted in Books, Origin of Life, Proteins, Random Stuff, RNA on January 12th, 2010 by Bradford

On page 344 of Signature in the Cell Meyer makes note of the interdependence of functionality existing in cells. The cellular relationships between DNA, ATP and proteins have sometimes been dubbed as the chicken-egg dilemma for origin of life explanations. Chicken-egg causal pathways are common to designed outcomes. They signal a logical point at which intelligent input can be indentified. But is a chicken-egg scenario compelling either for design or deniers of it? Meyer does more than leave the issue hanging.

The most highlighted approach to resolving the chicken-egg conundrum is probably the RNA world explanation. Its enzymatic and information storage properties are said to have been sufficient by proponents of the RNA world. The RNA world hypothesis has been much explored both at Telic Thoughts and within many other sites, papers and books.

Read the rest of this entry »

170 Comments »

What Meyer seeks to Explain

Posted in RNA, The Debate on January 10th, 2010 by Bilbo

At the end of chapter 5 ("The Molecular Labyrinth") of his book, Signature in the Cell, Stephen Meyer summarizes what he thinks needs to be explained:
…scientists investigating the origin of life must now explain the origin of at least three key features of life.

Read the rest of this entry »

18 Comments »

Resolving the RNA world Dispute

Posted in RNA on December 31st, 2009 by Bilbo

Agnostic chemist Robert Shapiro has claimed for decades that the RNA world scenario is too implausible, and that origin of life scientists should explore other alternatives. His message has largely fallen on deaf ears. Why?
Read the rest of this entry »

8 Comments »

An Ancient Time Frame

Posted in Origin of Life, RNA on November 29th, 2009 by Bradford

Deep-Sea Rocks Point To Early Oxygen On Earth is a Science Daily article. Quoting:

Red jasper cored from layers 3.46 billion years old suggests that not only did the oceans contain abundant oxygen then, but that the atmosphere was as oxygen rich as it is today, according to geologists.

The article goes on to explain that the amount of oxygen indicated implies that cyanobacteria, or organisms like it which produce oxygen, must have been found on earth at an earlier point in natural history than previously thought. Theories like the RNA world hold that a series of events involving catalytic RNA led to earth's first cells. Aside from findings like hematite which supply time frame limits, is there anything intrinsic to theorized RNA world processes indicating duration from start to the appearance of cyanobacteria like organisms?

40 Comments »

Other problems synthesizing RNA

Posted in RNA on September 1st, 2009 by Bilbo

There are two other problems with synthesizing RNA. The first is the presence of other substances. As Stephen Meyer points out: Read the rest of this entry »

1 Comment »

RNA Hard to Synthesize — Ribose

Posted in RNA on August 29th, 2009 by Bilbo

In Signature in the Cell Stephen Meyer presents five problems for the RNA world. The second part of the first problem involves the production of ribose, one of the constituents of RNA. Read the rest of this entry »

7 Comments »

RNA, Hard to Synthesize, Part I

Posted in RNA on August 28th, 2009 by Bilbo

In his book, Signature in the Cell, Stephen Meyer devotes a chapter to the RNA World scenario. He offers five problems that it faces. This thread will be devoted to the first part of the first problem: "RNA Building Blocks are Hard to Synthesize and Easy to Destroy." I'll just quote from his book. Read the rest of this entry »

52 Comments »

The Plausibility of the RNA World

Posted in Origin of Life, RNA on August 21st, 2009 by Bilbo

The question of the plausibility of the RNA world scenario has come up on the Information Content of Proteins thread. So I thought I better start an RNA world thread quick, before it takes over the discussion of proteins. So Gringo Royale and others, bring your discussion over here, please.

351 Comments »

More Fine-Tuning with RNA

Posted in RNA on August 25th, 2007 by MikeGene

From here:

Scientists have shown in literally thousands of studies that the p53 gene deserves its reputation as "the guardian of the genome." It calls to action an army of other genes in the setting of varied cell stresses, permitting repair of damaged DNA or promoting cell death when the cell damage is too great. A key net effect of p53's action is to prevent development of cancerous cells.

Now, University of Michigan Medical School scientists provide the most thorough evidence yet that p53 also regulates a trio of genes from the realm of so-called "junk" genes "” the roughly 97 percent of a cell's genetic material whose function is only beginning to be understood.

2 Comments »

Comparing Teleological Predictions with their Non-teleological Counterparts

Posted in Evolution, Intelligent Design, RNA on June 16th, 2007 by Bradford

The article ENCODE finds the human genome to be an active place, by John Timmer, is provacative. The issue it highlights serves as a useful focal point around which to contrast the predictive utility of a teleological approach with that of standard evolutionary thinking. This is particularly so since more data relevant to the junk DNA question soon will be forthcoming. From the article:

Read the rest of this entry »

49 Comments »

« Previous Entries
Next Page »
  • You are currently browsing the archives for the RNA category.

  • Featured Books

    Biased Embryos and Evolution by Wallace Arthur

  • The Design Matrix: A Consilience of Clues by Mike Gene


  • Pages

    • About Us
    • bipod
    • Bradford
    • Chunkdz
    • Deuce
    • Nullasalus
    • Techne
    • The Banned List
  • Categories

    • Animal Rights Extremism (40)
    • Approaches (20)
    • Astrobiology (6)
    • Bioethics (35)
    • Biology (213)
    • Books (25)
    • Brain (53)
    • Bunny Fright Week (7)
    • Cancer (1)
    • Causality (7)
    • Cell (32)
    • Climate Change (4)
    • Computer Science (9)
    • Convergent Evolution (7)
    • Cosmology (14)
    • Creationism (59)
    • Critical Thinking (5)
    • Culture Wars (25)
    • Design Inferences (43)
    • DNA Repair (4)
    • Engineering (19)
    • Eugenics (26)
    • Evidence (44)
    • Evo-Devo (12)
    • Evolution (315)
    • Evolutionary Psychology (14)
    • Fine-tuning (16)
    • Friday Quote (33)
    • Front-loading (172)
    • Gene's Gems (12)
    • Genetic Code (8)
    • Genome (12)
    • Guest Post (17)
    • Hating Mike (1)
    • Henry Rollins Award (3)
    • History (34)
    • Hoax (2)
    • Humor (181)
    • Information (12)
    • Intelligent Design (542)
    • Irreducible Complexity (28)
    • Junk DNA (4)
    • Just For Fun (31)
    • Law (2)
    • Media (95)
    • Meeting of Minds (9)
    • Memory Hole (1)
    • Metatalk (50)
    • MikeGenes World (22)
    • Modern Myths (9)
    • Morality (10)
    • Mutations (8)
    • Nanotechnology (2)
    • Natural Selection (32)
    • Nature (24)
    • Nature of Science (95)
    • Origin of Life (71)
    • Paul Mirecki (16)
    • Peer Review (12)
    • Peter Singer (3)
    • Philosophy (94)
    • Philosophy of Mind (40)
    • Physics (12)
    • Politics (18)
    • Post-Wedge World (21)
    • Proteins (14)
    • Quantum (6)
    • Quote Mining (9)
    • Random Stuff (275)
    • Religion (201)
    • Repost (34)
    • Richard Dawkins (105)
    • RNA (18)
    • Scandals (4)
    • Scholasticism (5)
    • School (62)
    • Science (205)
    • Scientific Boundaries (11)
    • Scientism (1)
    • Self-organization (2)
    • Shoddy Science (33)
    • Simulation Argument (2)
    • Stereotypes (7)
    • Systems Biology (3)
    • Teleology (9)
    • The Critics (261)
    • The Debate (326)
    • The Design Matrix (75)
    • The Duck (8)
    • The New Atheists (89)
    • The Rabbit (239)
    • Threatiness (85)
  • Evolution

    • Anthropology Weblog
    • Charles Darwin on the web
    • Darwin@home
    • Genetic Code Evolution
    • Kenneth Miller
    • NCSE
    • Stephen Jay Gould Archive
    • Talk Reason
    • Talk.Origins Archive
    • The Loom
    • The Panda's Thumb
    • Tree of Life
    • Was Darwin Wrong?
  • blogroll

    • Intelligently Sequenced
    • The Design Matrix
  • Teleology

    • Akilli Tasarim
    • An Evangelical Dialogue on Evolution
    • BioLogos
    • Edward Feser
    • Evolution Engineered
    • Evolution Oriented
    • Evolution und Schöpfung
    • Exiled from Groggs
    • ISCID EoSaP
    • Real Physics
    • Reality Cheque
    • Robin Collins
    • Teleomechanist
    • Telic Meme
    • The American Scientific Affiliation
    • The Creation of an Evolutionist
    • Thinking Christian
    • Thought Provoker
    • Wonders For Oyarsa
  • People With Interesting Ideas

    • Albert de Roos
    • Bradley Monton
    • Cell Intelligence
    • Darwin or Design
    • James Shapiro
    • Michael Syvanen
    • Panspermia
    • Paul Davies
  • Anti-Teleology

    • Center for Naturalism
    • Pharyngula
    • Richard Dawkins
  • Archives

    • May 2013
    • February 2013
    • November 2012
    • October 2012
    • September 2012
    • August 2012
    • July 2012
    • June 2012
    • May 2012
    • April 2012
    • March 2012
    • February 2012
    • January 2012
    • December 2011
    • November 2011
    • October 2011
    • September 2011
    • August 2011
    • July 2011
    • June 2011
    • May 2011
    • April 2011
    • March 2011
    • February 2011
    • January 2011
    • December 2010
    • November 2010
    • October 2010
    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • July 2010
    • June 2010
    • May 2010
    • April 2010
    • March 2010
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009
    • May 2009
    • April 2009
    • March 2009
    • February 2009
    • January 2009
    • December 2008
    • November 2008
    • October 2008
    • September 2008
    • August 2008
    • July 2008
    • June 2008
    • May 2008
    • April 2008
    • March 2008
    • February 2008
    • January 2008
    • December 2007
    • November 2007
    • October 2007
    • September 2007
    • August 2007
    • July 2007
    • June 2007
    • May 2007
    • April 2007
    • March 2007
    • February 2007
    • January 2007
    • December 2006
    • November 2006
    • October 2006
    • September 2006
    • August 2006
    • July 2006
    • June 2006
    • May 2006
    • April 2006
    • March 2006
    • February 2006
    • January 2006
    • December 2005
    • November 2005
    • October 2005
    • September 2005
    • August 2005
    • July 2005
    • June 2005
    • May 2005
    • Meta

      • Register
      • Log in

Telic Thoughts is proudly powered by WordPress
Hosting provided by TopSoftware4Download.com .

Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).